When international travelers visit Cartagena’s Historic Center with the hope of purchasing a Colombian emerald, they often arrive with some misconceptions. In the world of precious gems, many stories circulate that are not always true.To ensure you can make your investment with complete peace of mind and full knowledge, today we will debunk the three most common myths about emeralds and reveal the scientific reality behind this fascinating green stone.Myth 1: “Emeralds break very easily”• The Reality: There is a common belief that emeralds are extremely fragile stones that can break at the slightest touch. This is false. On the Mohs scale (the scientific measure used to evaluate the hardness of minerals), the emerald ranks between 7.5 and 8 out of 10. This means it is a very hard stone—much harder than steel or glass. It is true, however, that their natural inclusions—often referred to as an “internal garden”—can make them sensitive to very strong, direct impacts, especially along their edges. With normal care, an emerald ring can remain intact for generations.Myth 2: “A perfect emerald is one that has no internal marks”• The Reality: If someone offers you a large, completely clear, water-transparent emerald with no internal marks at a low price, be careful: it is most likely glass or synthetic plastic. Truly perfect natural emeralds practically do not exist on Earth. Those small lines, bubbles, or internal crystals are poetically called the “emerald’s garden” and serve as Mother Nature’s signature. They are absolute proof that the stone was formed millions of years ago within the Earth, rather than in a modern laboratory. Myth 3: “Large emeralds are always more expensive than small ones.”• The Reality: In fine jewelry, size is never everything. The value of a Colombian emerald is primarily determined by the intensity of its bluish-green color and its level of brilliance. A small, 0.5-carat emerald with a deep, electric green color and excellent transparency can be worth three times as much as a 3-carat stone that is opaque, milky, or a very pale green. When making a purchase, always prioritize the beauty of the color over the weight of the stone.
